Answers for The Penny Drops


This morning I was sent the following question in 2 tweets by a Labour tweeter, Caroline Penn:

@Ian4PCC Im considering my 2nd preference. Can you just answer the following questions? 1. As a church man, do you believe in women bishops? 2. Do you fully support equal marriage? 3. Do you fully support the current abortion law of 24 weeks? Thank you.

In the interests of openness and to avoid the restriction of answering the questions in 140 character bursts I am happy to answer here for Caroline and indeed anyone else who is interested in my personal opinions.

Firstly I must point out that these questions are completely unconnected to the role of Police Commissioner and in that sense they will not affect my role if elected in any way. Secondly I recognise an element that is consistent across the three which is that many people have got focused on the detail implicit in Caroline’s questions, and it is easy to miss the bigger picture in terms of the people involved. Finally none of these apply to me personally and so my view is somewhat distant from the direct consequences of these views. I apologise if my views do not respect the situation which impacts you.  

1) Women Bishops – There are no Bishops in my own church, but we have many women leaders. The ruling that allowed women to be Priests in the Church of England makes no sense if the Church does not enable women to also become Bishops. The current discussions are about when and how not if, and sadly the debate about the delays and special measures are sending out signals that the rest of us find very confusing. These concerns are important to those who hold them, but in my view the sooner one of the many wonderful possible candidates is selected as the first female Bishop the better.

2) Equal Marriage – In my view the 1837 Marriage Act opened the way for equal marriage decisions to be taken by the state but it has taken 175 years to get there. I  understand why so many people within and outside the church do not support the proposed change but that would be true of many other changes in our history. Marriage is a fantastic way of saying that one other person is special and making a lifetime commitment to them and I think any adult wishing to make such a commitment to another should be enabled to do so by the state. However I also recognise that there are views within most faith groups that place an additional dimension to this service which cannot be changed by the state or through legislation, it is clearly a matter for each of these groups to determine on what basis they will conduct their religious activities.

3) Abortion at 24 weeks – Like many people I recognise that the decision to end a pregnancy through abortion is a serious matter, and together we must work harder to reduce the number of unwanted pregnancies. A change of the termination date from 24 weeks does not appear to affect that in any way and a return to back street abortions would add nothing to our care for women who are faced with such a difficult situation. What we can do though is ensure that all women are supported to make the best decision in challenging circumstances.

About ianchisnall

I am passionate about the need for public policies to be made accessible to everyone, especially those who want to improve the wellbeing of their communities. I am particularly interested in issues related to crime and policing as well as health services and strategic planning.
This entry was posted in Charities, Parliament and Democracy and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Answers for The Penny Drops

  1. Caroline Penn says:

    Hi Ian,
    Firstly I wanted to thank you for taking the time to respond to me.
    While I appreciate these questions aren’t directly relevant to the PCC role, I do think issues of equality are particularly important to our diverse city.
    The protests that were held outside the abortion clinic in Dyke Road earlier this year concerned me greatly. At the time I did contact councillors, police & Caroline Lucas to see if more could be done to prevent the harassment of women at, as you say a very distressing time.
    I will consider you for my second preference & wish you the best of luck on the 15th.

    • ianchisnall says:

      Thank you Caroline. I agree with you regarding Abort 67 and I hope you will be reassured that many Christians and church leaders in the city share your concerns regarding their tactics. I personally visited the people concerned in Worthing to attempt to suggest alternative ways for them to express their concerns, so their freedom of speech was not lost but those who were on the receiving end were not the vulnerable young women who have been the target in the past. I fully accept that my commitment to equality principles is a vital part of any assessement of how suited I may be to the role of Police and Crime Commissioner.

  2. Alan Moroney says:

    And due to your replies, and having read carefully all your other info, I have made you my first preference, with Lib Dem candidate as second preference.
    Labour Candidate completely disqualified himself with some suggestions (I can only read between the lines), that he is very much of having a National System.

    Sorry, I love London, but it’s policing concerns are of no relevance to policing rural Sussex and small but urban Brighton (which has serious pockets of localised poverty but in a different way) etc.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s