It is clear from the public performances by Parliament over the last few days and some of the discussions I have personally sat through in less open settings at the same time that what we need in our nation, far more importantly than a clear decision about our departure or remaining in the EU is a new way by which public policies should be formed. The challenge is that all of us would need to play a part or at least express our views on a more frequent basis than once every five years or whenever Parliament agrees to hold an election, but then by its very nature those views would need to be listened and responded to unlike at present where our first past the post system determines who will be our representative and then in far too many ways our views and concerns as residents and workers get re-buried. When it came to a critical vote in Parliament last week about whether the legal advice given to the Cabinet should be shared with the rest of Parliament, after Parliament had called for this to happen and the Cabinet had refused to do so, all of our Sussex based Tory MPs voted against the will of Parliament. On the other hand across Brighton and Hove and in Eastbourne our four non Tory MPs all voted to ensure it did happen. When many Politicians do stand up to speak and claim that they have listened to the views of their electors, this seems to reverberate in a rather hollow way when votes are made in such a party dominated way. Although I don’t personally support the stance that Stephen Lloyd has taken in his decision to reject his party whip, I find his boldness to do so, in part because of the views of his constituents a very positive thing. Of course party dominance is not limited to votes on Cabinet decisions which thankfully in this case were overturned, it impacts on the way in which Councils operate both internally and in collaboration or a lack of collaboration with their neighbours, or in the case of Eastbourne and Lewes Councils their neighbours once removed. It is clear that a great many benefits have been achieved through the efforts by Adur and Worthing over the last decade. In one of my previous roles I had the privilege to sit on committees in West Sussex and saw some of the foundational work that was going on by people like Ian Lowrie who was firstly Chief Officer at Adur and then in Adur and Worthing before he retired from that role. The good work that has been achieved through that action and no doubt there have been problems too, needs to be carried out in many other places far more quickly if we are to see some benefits as a nation or even as a region as a whole. Clearly one of the biggest barriers to a more direct type of democracy is that communities would need to look beyond their own needs to ensure that a wider and greater good could be achieved. Clearly the times when this becomes a significant barrier is when local communities take to the streets to block things taking place in their back yard, even though the things being proposed could ultimately have a positive impact as long as they are planned well. Housing is one of the red rags that offends many people who live in every community whilst potentially offering a solution to many of the other people who live in the same areas, albeit in rooms and houses that no longer fit their needs very well. However if we could resolve such challenges, the prospect of ensuring that educational, training and health policies along with policies related to policing and other forms of blue light activity would be a better match to our community needs than those determined by Ministers whose roles and decisions seem to be heavily influenced by large businesses including investment bodies and newspaper owners and trade union officials. It is obvious that bottom up solutions would not work in isolation and there would need to be a healthy mix of bottom up and top down democracy. However removing more power from those at the top would lessen the impact of individuals who seem to currently attract extensive payments from organisations that want to control our society. Such a shift would also end the prospect of local government budget settlements from being delayed by debates and votes on matters such as our EU departure that should have been resolved months or even a year or so ago!
If you find any of these posts relevant to some of the social or political issues of the moment do leave a comment or contact me directly (click on my photo for my contact details)
Blog Stats
- 73,938 hits
-
Recent Posts
Archives
Top Rated
Categories
- Afghanistan (27)
- Brighton & Hove (602)
- Casey Review (5)
- Charities (493)
- Church Teaching (102)
- Community Safety (267)
- Data Retention and Investigatory Powers (17)
- Deaf & Hard of Hearing (60)
- Economics (540)
- Education (411)
- Environment (202)
- EU Referendum (537)
- Health Reform (110)
- Housing (77)
- Immigration (106)
- Journalism (128)
- Justice Issues (219)
- Lobbying Bill (65)
- Network Rail (61)
- Obituary (20)
- Parliament and Democracy (2,934)
- Phone Hacking (7)
- Planning Rules (56)
- Police & Crime Commissioner (202)
- Policing (391)
- Scottish Referendum (21)
- STEM (46)
- Syria (90)
- Think Tanks (15)
- UK Riots in August 2011 (15)
- Ukraine (14)
- Uncategorized (48)
- Welfare Reform (72)
- Yemen (44)
- Youth Issues (379)
Twitter Updates
- 365 days ago we set out a petition to call the Government to provide more funds for FareShare. A week ago two MPs (… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 2 hours ago
- I was delighted to attend on behalf of @AshdownAV you did a fantastic presentation and very welcome approach twitter.com/GBMETcoll/stat… 3 hours ago
- The Government must provide more funds for @FareShareUK as expressed by @jessicamordenmp and @ChrisStephens (and as… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 12 hours ago
- Hi @Tracy37162125 @StirFromBelow @LawnShapes @edwasp @landreferencing this is my blog today - The Lower Thames Cros… twitter.com/i/web/status/1… 23 hours ago
- Amber Rudd
- Andrew Griffith
- Boris Johnson
- Brexit
- Brighton & Hove
- Brighton & Hove City Council
- C-19
- Caroline Ansell
- Caroline Lucas
- Charities
- Charity Commission
- Charity Commission for England and Wales
- Chris Grayling
- Conservative Party
- Coronavirus
- COVID-19
- Daily Telegraph
- Daniel Hannan
- David Cameron
- David Davis
- Democracy
- Department for Education
- Donald Trump
- Eric Pickles
- EU Referendum
- European Union
- FareShare
- Foodbanks
- George Osborne
- Gillian Keegan
- Government
- Green Party
- Henry Smith
- Home Office
- House of Commons
- House of Lords
- Huw Merriman
- Iain Duncan Smith
- Independent Candidates
- Jacob Rees-Mogg
- Jeremy Corbyn
- Jeremy Hunt
- Katy Bourne
- Keir Starmer
- Labour Party
- Lib Dem Party
- Lloyd Russell-Moyle
- Lobbying Bill
- Local government
- Maria Caulfield
- Matthew Hancock
- Member of Parliament
- Michael Gove
- MPs
- NHS
- Nick Gibb
- Nigel Farage
- Nusrat Ghani
- Parliament
- Peter Bottomley
- Peter Kyle
- Police and Crime Commissioner
- Priti Patel
- Sajid Javid MP
- Sally-Ann Hart
- Small Businesses
- SME
- Sussex
- Sussex Police
- Syria
- Theresa May
- Tim Loughton
- Tony Blair
- UKIP
- YMCA Downslink Group